Piggy bank pension fund

French pensions still prioritize oil and gas instead of our future

A year ago, Reclaim Finance revealed that French pension bodies are supporting the development of fossil fuels, particularly through their investments. Whilst other French institutions, including Caisse des Dépôts and state-owned reinsurer Caisse Centrale de Réassurance, have announced plans to reduce or completely cease investing in the fossil fuel industry, three key pension institutions – Agirc-Arrco, ERAFP, and FRR – continue to fuel it. The NGO takes stock of the past year and calls on these pension bodies to immediately stop their support for the expansion of fossil fuels. 

Contributions from French citizens and public money feed into a pension system managed by several organisations that invest in the financial markets. Specifically: Agirc-Arrco (€91.2 billion in assets under management at the end of 2025) manages the supplementary pension scheme for private-sector employees and invests its reserves in financial assets; ERAFP (53.6 billion) is the pension fund responsible for civil servants' supplementary pensions; Fonds de reserve pour les retraites (FRR, 20.7 billion) is a public fund that contributes to the sustainability of pension schemes. 

Last year, a report by Reclaim Finance revealed these investors' support for the expansion of fossil fuels. Civil society thencondemned the fact that these practices were jeopardising the future of both present and future generations, contrary to these organisations' mission to secure the future of their beneficiaries. The investors were called to account by youth and student organisations and environmental groups, whilst members of the parliament tabled an amendment to ensure that FRR no longer invests in polluting companies (1). 

French pensions continue to finance oil and gas expansion through bonds

Despite this pressure, Agirc-Arrco has not announced any changes to its investment rules regarding the fossil fuel industry. ERAFP and FRR have announced a few changes (2) but still allow themselves to finance some of the world’s largest developers of oil and gas fields or liquefied natural gas terminals. They do so notably through bonds, one of the main sources of funding for fossil fuel expansion (3). Companies eligible for Agirc-Arrco and FRR include TotalEnergies, Eni and Saudi Aramco. TotalEnergies is eligible for ERAFP.

In 2025, these institutions still hold several hundred million euros in fossil fuel companies. Although these figures are down compared with 2024, these institutions have nevertheless been able to make new investments contributing to the development of oil and gas (4). Since July 2025, for example, FRR has purchased recent bonds issued by Venture Global LNG (€10.6 million worth of bonds held at the end of September 2026), OMG (€1.7 million) and Var Energi (€420,000).

Exposure of French pensions to fossil fuel companies

Exposure in 2024 (in million euros)  Exposure in 2025 (in million euros)  Methodology and scope (5) 
Agirc-Arrco  673  648  Holdings in fossil fuel companies as of 31 December 2024 and 2025, taking into account all their activities, excluding green bonds, calculated by Agirc-Arrco on the basis of the GCEL and GOGEL lists compiled by the NGO Urgewald. 
ERAFP  1,195  637  Holdings in companies generating more than 50% of their turnover from fossil fuels (extraction, transport, storage, refining and distribution) as of 31 October 2024 and 2025, taking into account all their activities. Estimate calculated by Reclaim Finance. 
FRR  883  820  Holdings in companies operating in the fossil fuels sector (mining, exploration, drilling and electricity generation) as of 31 December 2024 and 2025, taking into account all their activities. Estimate calculated by Reclaim Finance. 

Institutions lagging behind their peers

In contrast to pension bodies, Caisse des Dépôts – the public manager of French regulated savings accounts – announced in September that it would stop financing oil producers through bonds. 

Other French investors are going even further: the state-owned reinsurer (Caisse Centrale de Réassurance) announced in June that it would end new investments in developers of new oil and gas projects across the entire value chain – something the Ircantec pension body has been doing since 2021. 

Ineffective shareholder dialogue and complicit votes

Agirc-Arrco, ERAFP and FRR also continue to support fossil fuel companies in which they hold shares through complacent relationships and favourable votes at annual general meetings, even as several of these companies – such as TotalEnergies – are repeatedly backtracking on their climate ambitions (6).

These pension institutions claim to want to influence the climate strategies of the companies in their portfolios, but in reality, none of them specifies what sanctions are applied in the event of a lack of progress, nor what the implications are for their investment decisions. Furthermore, none of them publishes their votes at annual general meetings, nor does any indicate that it has voted against the leaders of fossil fuel expansionists this past year.

Persisting inaction with asset managers that are harmful to the climate

The three pension bodies delegate most of their investments to external asset managers, some of whom – such as BlackRock – are known for their climate backtracking, their massive support for the development of fossil fuels and their lobbying against the energy transition. Once again this year, ERAFP has awarded a new 'stand-by' mandate to BlackRock (7). For its part, Agirc-Arrco has not published a list of its asset managers. 

Whilst ERAFP and FRR have recently joined two initiatives aimed at encouraging asset managers to step up their climate action (8), this stated ambition is contradicted by the lack of sanctions imposed on managers who persist with their climate-damaging practices. At a time when several pension funds are withdrawing mandates from some asset managers due to sustainability concerns, French pension institutions must urgently review their selection criteria to avoid entrusting our pensions to organisations that support the development of fossil fuels. 

Protecting pensions means safeguarding the environmental and social conditions under which current and future generations will be able to benefit from them. A world in which the expansion of fossil fuels unchecked global warming does not meet these conditions. Agirc-Arrco, ERAFP and FRR must immediately end their support for the expansion of fossil fuels, which is leading us towards this situation.

Notes:

  1. French National Assembly, Amendment No. 1471 to the draft Social Security Financing Bill for 2027 (in French), tabled on 16 October 2026
    French Senate, Amendment No. 1733 to the Social Security Financing Bill for 2027 (in French), tabled on 6 November 2026 
  2. For more information, you can read the follow articles by Reclaim Finance:
    Reclaim Finance, 6 February 2026, Fonds de réserve pour les retraites: public money still serving fossil fuels
    Reclaim Finance, 17 February 2026, ERAFP's new climate commitments: progress or window dressing? 
  3. Most of the new capital allocated to the fossil fuels sector comes from debt markets.
    University of Cambridge, August 2026, The Cambridge Framework for assessing corporate climate action | Department of Land Economy
    Theodor F Cojoianu, Francisco Ascui, Gordon L Clark, Andreas G F Hoepner, Dariusz Wójcik, Does the fossil fuel divestment movement impact new oil and gas fundraising?, Journal of Economic Geography, Volume 21, Issue 1, January 2021, Pages 141–164, https://doi.org/10.1093/jeg/lbaa027 
  4. Exposure to fossil fuel companies corresponds to the stock of investments held by an investor on a given date. It differs from the flow of fossil fuel investments over a given period, which corresponds to assets newly invested in fossil fuel companies. A decline in fossil fuel exposure therefore does not mean that the investor made no new fossil fuel investments over the past year. The investor may well have made new investments totalling less than the proceeds from the sale of financial assets or bonds maturing over a given period. In that case, the investor contributed to the financing of fossil fuels during that period. 
  5. The figures for Agirc-Arrco are taken directly from the scheme's report on the implementation of SRI policies. The figures for ERAFP and FRR are estimates calculated by Reclaim Finance, which were shared with these two institutions prior to the publication of our article.
    The methodologies differ for each organisation. The figures are therefore not directly comparable. 
  6. In September, TotalEnergies announced an increase in its oil and gas production target, having already raised this target and reduced its planned investment in its 'low-carbon' activities in recent years. And in March, the company abandoned its goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2050. 
  7. ERAFP, 13 August 2026, L'ERAFP attribue neuf mandats de gestion d'actifs non cotés de capital investissement et d'infrastructure (in French)
    A 'stand-by' mandate may be activated by ERAFP in the coming years, depending on its needs. 
  8. ERAFP and FRR have joined the 'Asset Owner Statement on Climate Stewardship' initiative and have signed a declaration by asset owners encouraging asset managers to sign up to the Net Zero Asset Managers initiative.
    Net Zero Investor, 20 October 2025, Eight new asset owners sign statement outlining asset manager climate expectations
    Net Zero Asset Managers, 25 January 2026, Asset Owner Statement on Net Zero Asset Managers (NZAM) 

Read also

2026-11-20T09:52:04+01:00